NI dealers face MOT upgrade wait until 2029

Staff
By Staff
4 Min Read

Northern Ireland dealers face years of further disruption after a £10.8 million vehicle testing upgrade failed to deliver.

A Northern Ireland Audit Office (NIAO) investigation found weaknesses in the procurement and contractual arrangements used by the Driver and Vehicle Agency (DVA), which operates Northern Ireland’s MOT testing network.

The contract, awarded in March 2019, was terminated through a negotiated settlement in April 2025 after six years of delivery problems, disputes and legal challenges.

The failure cost the DVA approximately £5.1m, including £3.6m in staff and other costs and a £1.5m settlement payment to the contractor.

Unlike Great Britain, where MOT testing is carried out by authorised private garages, vehicles in Northern Ireland must be inspected at one of 15 DVA testing centres. The agency processes more than one million tests annually, making capacity and appointment availability.

Failed bid was 53% cheaper

The successful £10.8m bid was 53% lower than the only other compliant tender, which was priced at £23m. It was also 40% below the DVA’s £18.1m business case estimate.

Although further checks were carried out, the Audit Office concluded that these did not provide sufficient assurance that the system could be delivered at the price quoted.

The proposed IT system also received limited scrutiny before the contract was awarded and became a major point of disagreement between the DVA and its contractor.

The DVA first attempted to terminate the agreement in 2022, but the contractor successfully challenged that decision in the High Court. The court found that milestone dates relied upon by the agency were not contractually binding.

A second termination attempt was made in 2024 before the parties reached an out-of-court settlement in April 2025.

Comptroller and auditor general Dorinnia Carville described the project as a “missed opportunity to improve much needed services” and a “significant waste of public money”.

The original programme was expected to provide capacity for up to 200,000 additional tests each year through new facilities at Hydebank and Mallusk.

Replacement due by mid-2029

The failure has delayed the planned testing improvements by more than four years, leaving the DVA dependent on overtime and Temporary Exemption Certificates to manage demand.

Waiting times for vehicle tests peaked at more than 100 days during 2023. The average subsequently fell from 59 days in 2023-24 to 33 days in 2024-25, partly because exemption certificates reduced immediate demand.

A replacement contract worth approximately £46m was awarded in March 2026. Delivery will begin with a pilot testing lane and installation at Hydebank before moving to Mallusk and the remaining DVA centres.

The replacement system is expected to be fully delivered by mid-2029, with maintenance continuing until 2035-36. The Audit Office said the £46m figure could not be directly compared with the original contract because its scope, delivery period and maintenance requirements had changed.

Sue Robinson, chief executive of the National Franchised Dealers Association (NFDA), said: “These findings are deeply concerning, particularly given the significant amount of public money spent without delivering the improvements that were promised.

“Reliable and efficient vehicle testing services are essential for motorists and automotive retailers alike. Prolonged delays and continued reliance on temporary measures create unnecessary uncertainty for businesses and consumers.

“It is crucial that meaningful improvements follow this. Future investment must deliver value for taxpayers and a vehicle testing system should meet the needs of the industry.”

Ensure you always receive AM insights. Make us a preferred source of news on Google

Share This Article
Leave a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *